With all of the great headlines coming from the Pirate Bay trial over the past few weeks, I have really been thinking about how hard it must be for both sides to make their case.
Copying software, music or movies without paying for them is illegal. Anything that is illegal is wrong.
I was at the Goodwill this week and looking through their CD collection this week and it got me to wondering if buying a used CD was technically legal. The artist has collected the royalties from the original sale, but does that make it OK?
Are libraries legal? Every book I read from the library is a book that I will likely never buy. Same goes for magazines. I can go to the library and read any issue of any magazine without having to subscribe. Today most libraries even have music and movies available for checkout.
True, someone has paid for those items, but what about all of the lost sales and royalties from people who borrowed but didn’t buy?
Back to my Goodwill analogy, if I buy a shirt from Goodwill that is still in new or near-new condition, am I stealing royalties from the designer?
If the fact that the library, thrift store or yard sale host has already paid for these items, doesn’t that weaken case against file sharing and illegal piracy.
If someone pays for a song then gives it to someone else, is that illegal? Yes.
If someone buys a Rolex then lets each of his neighbors wear it on alternating days, is that illegal? No.
If someone buys a fake Rolex, pirated copy of Windows or pirated movie, and they never would have purchased the item otherwise, are royalties lost?
I need to be clear, I am not writing in support of piracy. I am just trying to follow the logic behind the various anti-piracy laws. While it may sound crazy, I also wonder if it will be illegal a few years from now for libraries, thrift stores and yard sales to have certain items for sale.