Novatel Wireless MiFi 2200 Mobile Hotspot review

The Novatel Wireless MiFi 2200 has the potential to revolutionize portable computing. I believe it could revive the use of laptops for travel.

I stopped carrying a laptop years ago. It stopped making sense to carry a laptop that weighed over four pounds – just in case I needed to use it in a public hotspot location with an open WiFi signal. When netbooks came out, I rejoiced because it meant I could have less to lug around. However hotspots are rare, and unsecured wireless connections are even more rare.

My smartphone does a great job for using Twitter, Facebook and reading general news, but it cannot be considered a productivity tool or laptop replacement for day-to-day jobs.

It seems that desktops are being replaced by large laptops, netbooks and smartphones are replacing portable laptops and everyone is mad because Internet access is becoming less ubiquitous as companies find new ways to charge for it.

Now, on to the review. The Novatel Wireless MiFi 2200 is an EVDO modem – but it is oh, so much more. Once configured, the MiFi also becomes a battery powered hotspot for up to five devices. The MiFi is not a WiFi repeater, it is an EVDO modem with a built-in wireless access point.

The device is exactly the dimensions as a credit card and thinner than an iPhone.

The MiFi has a removable and rechargeable Li-ion battery that is rated for 4 hours use and 40 hours standby. See link in first paragraph for all the tech specs. The unit is charged either via the USB cable from your PC or via the included travel charger. The connection on the device itself is micro USB (see images above).

The MiFi 2200 is actually two devices in one. If connected to the computer directly, the device acts as an EVDO modem allowing the computer to connect to the web via software that comes stored on the device itself. If the device is plugged into the wall or run wirelessly from the battery, you connect to the web via the operating systems’ wireless connectivity manager. When setup as hotspot the device allows up to five devices to connect to the web via WiFi.

Data speeds in Grand Junction, CO, where I tested it, weren’t fantastic, but they did the job. I continually received .5Mbps connection speeds for both up and download. The device is rated for up to 3.1Mbps down and 1.8 upload. The device we reviewed was running on the Verizon 3G network which is much slower in Grand Junction than the Sprint 3G. It would be interesting to compare the Sprint MiFi with the Verizon version and see if there was a noticeable speed difference. Although .5Mbps isn’t great, it was more than sufficient

for the reasons I carry a laptop – web surfing, Twitter, Facebook, blogging, etc.

The MiFi is a fantastic product and it is extremely easy to use. The only manual configuration required was typing the 11-digit password to connect to the WiFi. Running it as a modem took a few minutes, but it was all waiting for bars to move across the screen as the software installed and occasionally clicking on the affirmative during the questions asked during the standard software install process.

As I mentioned in the opening paragraph, the MiFi has the potential to change the landscape of mobile computing. However, there is one disadvantage that has nothing to do with the product itself. The service is extremely expensive. It is difficult to pinpoint the target market for the MiFi under the current rates.

The perfect customer for this product has $60 per month (Sprint or Verizon) to spend on their already high cell phone bill , a type of work that needs to be done constantly monitored on a web platform that won’t work with a smartphone, and little access to public hotspots. This includes a small percentage of business travelers, rich people who live in rural suburbs and folks who just have to have the latest gadget. The price makes in impractical for students, teachers and others who would find it the most useful.

With every McDonald’s, Borders, Barnes & Noble and countless hotels and coffee shops offering free or inexpensive WiFi, it is difficult find the market that believes that $60 per month is worth not having to wait until they can get to a hotspot.

An argument can be made for the last mile, but chances are that most people living in the last mile don’t have EVDO access either. There are also many ISPs offering HSDPA Internet service. Although HSDPA services generally only cover a specific region, they do address the last mile, ubiquitous WiFi within geographic boundaries and generally cost less than EVDO while offering better connection speeds.

It is difficult to say where the ubiquitous WiFi path will lead to next, but at $60 per month, the MiFi is a little short changed. It’s too bad because the product would really take off it rates were reasonable.

Share this post:
  • Print
  • email
  • RSS
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Add to favorites
  • Fark
  • FriendFeed
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Sphinn

Tweets from the week 2010-02-03

  • The MiFi 2200 is very cool – but not $60/mo cool. #CES #
  • RT @MarkClayson: Google Nexus One: Now With Multitouch http://goo.gl/fb/hkVZ <- Good news in reply to MarkClayson #
  • RT @laughingsquid: WordPress for Android 1.0 has been released http://bit.ly/cBxwjH #
  • http://twitpic.com/112idr – Verizon MiFi will be posted soon on talkingdigital.org #
  • Very recent photos from Haiti – http://bit.ly/btmMXD #
  • I'm at Mesa State College (1100 North Ave., 12th, Grand Junction). http://4sq.com/cmbMeR #
  • http://twitpic.com/10i74q – Got my car egged last night. Just one egg. #
  • RT @socialbflyco: @shupe Welcome to GJ! Can't wait to see you at Pork & Hops again this Sept! #gjco #
  • I love that people from Boston, Ireland and Japan have troubles saying the word "iPad" http://bit.ly/a1QUOz New York Times link. #
  • Woot Off!!!! #fb #
  • I have to admit that the powerpress Blubrry folks are on top of things. Very unusual for OpenSource #wordpress #OpenSource #
  • The iPad will do to Amazon's market share what the new Nano did to the Flip video market. It's too complicated to be an eReader. #
  • Why didn't Apple just make the iPad a large screen iPhone/iPod Touch docking station? #iPad #Apple #iPhone #
  • I love the big black border around the iPad. I love how it emphasizes the lack of a camera and makes the screen look smaller. #ipad #
  • RT @kwbridge: iPass <- iCouldn't agree more. Very disappointing. No digital camera? No GPS? No Flash? etc. #
  • To everyone who expected Apple to announce something more than a big expensive iPod Touch. – sorry. #fb #
  • Pixar is hiring. http://bit.ly/b5zelW #

Powered by Twitter Tools

Share this post:
  • Print
  • email
  • RSS
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Add to favorites
  • Fark
  • FriendFeed
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Sphinn
Tags: ,

03

02 2010

The real debate: Is the iPad a big iPhone, a big iPod Touch or a crippled iMac?

apple media pad itablet concept

Ya. We know, the photo used here is not of the actual iPad (Creative Commons License photo credit: nDevilTV).

Apple has described the iPad as the most innovative piece of technology they have ever produced. This may be true if you take it apart and look at the pieces, but the end result is a device that is actually strong in it’s non-innovative approach.

Perhaps, it would have been nice to see a larger screen, a slide-out keyboard, a digital camera/video, true GPS, full OS X, an OLED or color eInk screen, and innovative features that have never been seen before. However, a few years from now we may look back and realize that it may be the iPad’s similarity to the iPhone and iPod Touch that make it a success for Apple.

The iPad is actually an answer to complaints from iPhone and iPod Touch users. The larger screen and ability to attach peripherals are the only real differences between Apple’s current touch screen devices and the iPad.

But, is the screen big enough and will people use a device that is missing some of the features that make the iPhone attractive?

Where would Twitter, FourSquare, Yelp!, and mobile Google Maps be without the iPhone. Sure, there are plenty of smartphones that use these services, but would those companies have reached their current value had it not been for the iPhone. The even bigger question is would the iPhone be as popular had these services not found innovative uses for the camera, GPS and overall awareness of the iPhone?

iPad discussions on Twitter and in forums seem to be full of debates on whether the iPad is good enough to be useful to current iPhone and iPod Touch users. And then there’s the Netbook crowd. A nicely equipped netbook costs roughly $200-$300 less than the iPad.

Whether or not the iPad is a hit will depend on the actual needs of users, not the hype that Apple has put behind it. A table on Apple’s website has a price breakdown for each model.

Once cost not covered on this chart is the additional $15-$30 per month for the 3G service (only offered by AT&T). $30 per month for 3G data is a very good deal when you compare it to the cost of other networks data plans or even data plans on AT&T for other devices. If the iPad has a killer feature, this is it. On the other hand, most wireless providers offer a USB 3G wireless adapter that can be plugged into any netbook or notebook for roughly $50 per month.

The question is whether people will pay $629 (or more) plus $15-$30 per month ($180-$360) for a data service that can only be used on a single device. Compare the $629+$180 minimum for a 3G iPad which only offers 16GB of storage, no webcam, and no tactile keyboard to almost any $300 netbook with a 3G dongle or built-in 3G. The pricing is roughly the same. However, the added cost in getting a netbook plus USB 3G dongle allows you to pick your 3G service, you will likely get 160GB or more in storage, a webcam, a tactile keyboard. The USB dongle route allows you to use the 3G service on other device.

On the other hand, if you go the iPad route, you will have a cool device with a touch screen. You will also get noticed in coffee shops as you sit with your neck at a right angle pressing the keys of the onscreen keyboard as you punch out an email that say something like…

Bob,

Got your message. I will write more when I get to a real computer.

Thanks,

Bob

Sent from my iPad

To other iPad users this message will show that you cared enough to hit the function keys that allowed you to make a few punctuation marks. Of course, there is a full QWERTY keyboard available for the iPad. It is important to note that spending the extra $60 on the keyboard will bring you to within $30 of the price difference of going the netbook route. If you choose the 64GB version and unlimited data, then you surpassed the cost of a netbook a long time ago.

If anything, Apple has open the doors for a real non-Windows competitor to step in and steal the market share from anyone who is not a brand loyalist (fanboi).

The instant on, 3G and touch screen are nice features that make the iPad unique. That helps competitors who want to go to the cost and expense define what their competing product needs. We hope it means an Android-based tablet with a real keyboard and OLED or color eInk display. Throw in a webcam, real GPS and the 3G service of the customer’s choosing and you have a device that could win big among people who consider features over brand. Apple has opened the gates on the $500+ price point for a small screen. This allows competitors to come in and offer better equipped devices for a lower cost.

The big question will be whether OS X is enough to draw enough buyers over competing products. The operating system is the only feature that competitors cannot duplicate. If Windows were the only option, the iPad would be a solid winner. Linux, Android, Chrome and even WebOS are always lingering out there for customers and manufacturers who are willing to break with Apple and Windows and try something different.

It’s an exciting time to be a geek.

Share this post:
  • Print
  • email
  • RSS
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Add to favorites
  • Fark
  • FriendFeed
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Sphinn

Tweets from the week 2010-01-27

  • Sweet! There is development on Podpress again! Please help contribute if you know how. http://bit.ly/bzEAb5 #wordpress #podcast #opensource #
  • I am having my class at Mesa State create a 21st century newspaper online. Stay tuned for domain and to watch the project progress #gjco #
  • Wish a voice recording app would come out for the #Pre. #
  • At least somebody is using WolframAlpha http://bit.ly/8lfm6a #
  • Keep an eye on @HelpMeRick for some sweet #sundance updates. I wish I was there. #
  • getting ready to review the Yeti by @bluemicrophones watch for the review soon at http://bit.ly/5e6TBQ talkingdigital.org #podcast #review #
  • Picking out balloons for a party. Reminds me of Raising Arizona. Is round a funny shape? #
  • Homeschoolers learning physics by building catapults. None of them were bored. http://twitpic.com/z3vpy #fb #
  • Homeschoolers preparing for the revolution by building catapults #
  • RT @adamcoomes: 100% confirmed photo of an Apple Tablet! http://is.gd/6GwPD #
  • We are live talking about #CES on http://kafmradio.org #

Powered by Twitter Tools

Share this post:
  • Print
  • email
  • RSS
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Add to favorites
  • Fark
  • FriendFeed
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Sphinn
Tags: ,

27

01 2010

Tweets from the week 2010-01-20

Twitter Bird
Creative Commons License photo credit: tashmahal

  • Missing Palm #Pre Apps – barcode scanner, flickr uploader, video app, any game that couldn’t have run on the Palm V, etc. #
  • Is looking like you need a facelift really worse than looking like you’ve had a facelift? #
  • I triple dog dare you to follow me! Oh yes – I just did that. #
  • RT @TopsyRT: Square iPhone Payment System [video] – Kevin Rose http://is.gd/6tDsG #
  • Most useless gadget seen at #CES http://bit.ly/4ECvW6 #
  • RT @MarkClayson: The FBI Sucks at Photoshop [PIC] http://bit.ly/5zLTkA <- That’s funny. #
  • I have as many tweets as @leolaporte either I am tweeting too much or he doesn’t tweet enough. #
  • http://twitpic.com/yditd – The new OR at St. Mary’s Hospital #gjco The last state of the art h ospital #
  • The coolest stuff you didn’t hear about at #CES http://bit.ly/8AQ7tu # Read the rest of this entry →
Share this post:
  • Print
  • email
  • RSS
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Add to favorites
  • Fark
  • FriendFeed
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • Sphinn
Tags: ,

20

01 2010


Powered by eShop v.4

Theme Tweaker by Unreal
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States
This work by adamc is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States.